Think up two social networks of which you are currently a member. Analyze the structure of each of these networks, make clear what the dependency relationships are, and what coordinative mechanisms are used.
In our daily lives, most of us take part in many social networks. We go to school, we go to work, we have families, we go to or even organize events and so on. All these social networks have distinct structures and interesting dependency relations.
Figure 1: Examples of network structures (Frank Boons 2013)
These networks can be structured in several ways. In figure A the network is tightly coupled. Each point has multiple connections, making communication in this network quite easy. In B there are two cliques. In this type of structure, interaction between the two groups Is absent. In figure D, we see the bridging of a structure hole. Three individuals are causing an interaction between two groups. In C there is centrality. Interaction within the members of this group is via a central figure.
As most readers and writers of the IE-blogs already should know, there are four types of coordination mechanisms. Let’s look at these mechanisms from a network perspective.
Self-organization: emergent patterns in interacting individuals.
Self-governance: network of private actors engaged in rule formation, monitoring and sanctioning.
Private interest government: intersecting networks of private and public actors.
Government: interlinked networks of public actors engaged in rule formation, monitoring and sanctioning. (Frank Boons 2013)
Now, let’s look at two social networks of which I was a member of.
Internship at Universiteit Leiden
To complete my BSc. In Biology, I had to take a research internship for one semester at the Institute of Biology(IBL) in Leiden. The IBL is a department of the Leiden University. My research topic was grammatical rule-learning in Zebra Finches. When I was admitted to the internship, I had to sign a form together with my supervisors and the professor. The supervisors (PhD students) where there to guide me in the research and I could contact them on daily basis if I had problems or questions. The professor, on the other hand, was in touch on daily basis with my supervisors. The professor and I had a meeting once every month, to discuss the study and the findings.
Network Structure
Figure 2: Network structure internship
The structure of this organization (Fig. 2) can be described as a tightly coupled network where the actors are connected in more than one way to different parts of the network. A PhD student for example is, like an intern, connected to Leiden University, the IBL, the Professor and to the Dutch government. It is very clear that all actors in this network structure are directly and indirectly connected to each other.
Coordination Mechanisms
Several coordination mechanisms take place in this structure. Self-organization within the group of interns for example. Because there was a large group of interns this year, there were some issues, with space and materials that were used. After a few weeks, a system emerged, where we shared the scarce materials in a, in our eyes, fair way. Also, everyone did go for a break on a different time, because of the lack of space in the lunch room. Also, between me and my supervisors, self-organization emerged. This was the case for asking questions, taking breaks and even having chats.
Off course there is also self-governance. Several rules and regulations regarding internship, examination, studygoals en credits where applied to us in this internship. Some of these rules where even opposed by the government or other public domains. This brings us to Private Interest Government. Ethical regulations regarding animal treatment were strictly controlled. Other examples of this are the rules of the Ministry of Education regarding credits and internships.
Dependencies
There were several dependencies in this network structure. The PhD students where for instant dependent on interns helping them with their research. The University, the professor, the IBL, the PhD students and most other students are dependent on the government for funding research and education. There is also a dependency on feed stock for the animals, electricity and other material and energy flows from the surrounding area.
Voluntary work for the International Film Festival in Rotterdam
The International Film Festival in Rotterdam (IFFR) is a yearly phenomenon in the city of Rotterdam. For 10 days, all the cinema's in the city are screening international art-house films. People from all over the world are visiting the city for this big event. The festival is dependent on the thousands of volunteers who are willing to participate in this event. The volunteers are doing quite important jobs. I was sitting in a ticket-office for example. Selling tickets to the customers.
The structure of this organization can be described as a tightly coupled network where the actors are connected in more than one way to different parts of the network.
In this large organization, several control mechanisms take place. Private interest government is one mechanism that takes place. The festival needs to meet and follow several laws and restrictions that are set by the municipality of Rotterdam en the government of the Netherlands. Examples are: safety restrictions and laws regarding salary and work.
Self-governance is also taking place. And this is a mechanism to which I was subjected to when I participated in the voluntary work for the festival. Several rules for voluntary workers were applied and these rules were controlled. Examples are: controlling the amount of money in the ticket offices, sanctioning volunteers who didn’t come to work and rewarding extraordinary accomplishments. There was also self-organization. We as volunteers developed a way of helping each other, communicating via a Whatsapp-group and making solutions for problems that occur inevitably during the work.
Regarding to the dependencies, the IFFR is very dependent on many other organizations. They need the infrastructure and cinema’s in Rotterdam for the screening of the movies, the core business of the IFFR. Without the cinema’s, electricity and a good transport-infrastructure, the IFFR couldn’t take place.
They need film-producers to make the movies. They also need the volunteers to participate in the IFFR, because if they had the same amount of paid workers, the IFFR wouldn’t be a feasible event.
No comments:
Post a Comment