Wednesday, November 27, 2013

Assignment 7



Define industrial ecology in a way that fits with your national culture, and make explicit what the specific national elements in your definition are.


National Culture
The title says it all. For this weeks blog we have to make a definition of Industrial Ecology that defines 'our national culture'. But what is 'my' national culture? The facts are that I am born and raised in the Netherlands. I have been to school here, I have worked here,my friends live here, so my world of reference is as you can say Dutch.
On the other hand, I must say, there is always a debate about who is Dutch and what it means to be Dutch. There will be always people who see me, because of my foreign roots, as a foreigner or as an immigrant. My solution for that problem is to ignore those people. And maybe being a 'relative outsider' provides me even with a more objective look at things.

Dutch National Culture
Off course 'Dutch National Culture' is not a static or uniform concept. There are some traditional differences between the Northern parts of the country and the Southern parts of the country that go back to the 'Pillarization' (verzuiling). Pillarization the vertical segregated division of the society in different pillars. In the Northern and bigger part of the country the culture was mainly Protestant (Calvinistic). In the Southern part of the country there was, and to some extent still is, a Catholic culture. Apart from that there was a Socialist and a Liberal pillar, who had the highest amount of  'members' in the cities. Even after the 'depillarization' started in the sixties, these regional, political and cultural differences are sometimes quite apparent.
Also, nowadays, cultures of immigrant groups play a role in the Netherlands, mainly in the cities.
Off course this doen't mean that there is no common 'Dutch culture' with shared values and traditions. But, like in all countries with big populations, regional differences are important and should be noticed.

Industrial Ecology and Dutch Culture
Industrial Ecology is about sustainability, waste treatment, and resources. There is actually a good analogy with Calvinist values. Modesty and living a sober live are virtues in Calvinism. When people live this way, this can reduce the depletion of national resources and waste outflows. On the other hand Weber sees Calvinism as an important factor in the rise of capitalism. But Weber doesn't address capitalism in a stereotypical way as an ideology of greed but as an ideology of human progress trough hard work.

Regarding to Hofstedes model the Netherlands is a feminine country. What according to Hofstede means "that the dominant values in society are caring for others and quality of life. A feminine society is one where quality of life is the sign of success and standing out from the crowd is not admirable." Industrial Ecology can be used to make work of these values. If we get a good insight in the material and energy flows, we can help to reduce global warming, euthrofication and toxic waste. Caring for others and the quality of life are good motivations for that.

But regarding to Hofstede, the Netherlands has an individualistic and shot-term oriented culture. Individualism off course, doesn't mean egoism or not caring about others. This also wouldn't make sense, because of the high score in feminineness. It's about the how tight or loose the social system is knit and to what extent it's expected from individuals to take care of other people outside of their family. But anyhow, a tighter knit social system may be better context for collective action to environmental problems. Also, Industrial Ecology is about long-term oriented problems and goals. The shot term orientation is not

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Assignment 6

Think up four ways in which government can increase the use of LCAs through external control and setting boundary conditions. Use Sabatier’s framework to assess the potential effectiveness of external control vis-a-vis other options.

The LCAs is  a tool to get an insight to environmental impacts associated with a product from the 'cradle to the grave'. Getting this insight makes it possible to reducte this environmental impacts, because you can see where in the product-chain which impacts take place. When governments want to increase the use of this tool (as part of environmental politics) they have the possibility to use different ways of doing that. I will look at four possible ways for a government to increase the use of LCAs. To asses the potential effectiveness, I will use Sabatiers's framework (Sabatier 1980) which describes the stages and problems regarding public policy making and implementation.


Regulation
(1)There are several ways for the government increase the use of LCAs. The most direct way of this would be to enforce the use of LCAs by making it mandatory. And they will have a penalty if they don't. This method however is quite harsh and can create some problems. First, it is costly for firms to make LCA's. So if you do this only within a country, you would damage the competitiveness of the firms in that nation. Apart from that, firms will leave to other countries because of this costly obligation. So if you do this, you will need an international approach. This will not reduce the costs and will make things definitely not easier.
Secondly, you need an external control mechanism. And this is also quite costly.
Also, if you obligate firms to this you need a big amount of people who can actually do some LCA's. The government would have to set boundary conditions. And that is that we need more schools and colleges where people are educated to perform LCA's. And off course students who are willing to invest time and money to learn this, but this will be the case in all alternatives.

Financial incentive
(2)A different approach is to reward companies that use LCA's for their products. A subsidy for firms who use LCA is good way for this. This will also take away the problem with international competitiveness of the firms. Still, the government will need control mechanisms and regulations for this. The uses of financial incentives like in the first and second way is called a 'statutory'

Influencing consumer behavior
A third way is to make the public aware of the use of LCAs and how LCAs can give an insight in emissions and help to find a way to reduce these emissions. A good way to do this will be a LCA-label. Companies that use LCAs for their prodcuts will get a label and can use this label when they are advertising their products. The government can make the public aware of this label and the meaning of it with 'commercials' on National TV and the Radio. If we make the assumption that consumers care about (reducing) emissions and will choose for products that have the LCA-label, than this can be a good way for increasing the use of LCA. These way of creating public awareness and media attention are called 'non-statuary variables' by Sabatier. 

Setting an example
The fourth way is for the government to set an example. The government nowadays is very big organization who consumes a lot of products. The government should in this method only use products from firms that use LCAs for their products. This could have three effects. The first effect is that the use of LCA will increase because the government is such a big organization. The use of LCA will also increase because firms that are planning or wanting to sell their products to the governemnt will make use of LCAs. The third possible effect is, because of the high increase of the use LCAs, public awareness of the phenomenon will increase and consumers may pay attention to it when they buy products.



Sabatier, P., & Mazmanian, D. D. (1980). The Implementation of Public Policy: A Framework of Analysis. Policy Studies Journal, 8(4), page 538-560