Thursday, September 26, 2013

The Fyra-debacle: Rational decision making

Fyra was a high-speed rail service that operated between Amsterdam and Brussels that operated less then a month. The high profile project was a collaboration between the Dutch NS Hispeed and the Belgian NMBS. Fyra had much problems from the start on. Parts of the train were coming down and some people even noted that they saw that parts of the train were held together by duct-tape. The train was soon called 'ALDI-Trein' by the public, referring to a Germany-based discount supermarket.

The story of the Fyra train starts as early as in 1973. The Dutch government of that time, lead by Den Uyl, made the first plans for a high-speed rail line from Schiphol to the Belgian border. The aim of the project was to connect Amsterdam to Brussels and Paris with a high speed rail line. The construction of the actual project started not before 2000 and the line was finished in 2006. The total costs of the construction was estimated by the government to be 3.5 billion euro's but in 2006,  6.8 billion euro's was spent. The budged was exceeded by 97%! But this is just where the story of the Fyra starts.

The NS, the Dutch railway company, was just privatized. The NS found it very important for the future of the company to operate on the new high speed rail line. By rational reasoning, they figured out that if the NS wanted to stay the biggest player in the Dutch market, they had to operate on the high speed rail lines. The company paid a high amount of money to get the deal. Twice as much as other foreign companies wanted to pay.
So they had to be penny-pinching from now an. The lack of money lead to the decision that they had to make a reduction in the price for the trains they had to buy. They choose for the cheapest option., which was the Fyra. They assumed that this train, despite being not that impressive, was good enough do to the job. 


Decision based on boundedly rational organization:

Now let's look at this case from the perspective of bounded rationality. Many factors play a role in the decision making process in different levels.
In the first decision of NS, the idea that NS has to stay the largest player on the Dutch market has different bounded rational arguments. For example, the fact that NS was the state-monopolist not long ago might have lead to some routines, rules and standard operating procedures that were the main forces behind this idea.
Also the cultural values might have played a big role. The idea that a Dutch company with a historical value should operate on the Dutch high-speed rail line is not very unthinkable for people in charge of NS, or for general public in the Netherlands. People who work at NS identified strongly with this organization. In such an organization, change is very difficult.

In the second decision, the order of the cheapest trains, several things seem to have gone wrong. The fact that two huge companies (Dutch NS and Belgian NMBS) were involved in this process, can have caused a problem in the processing of information. Parallel processing can go really wrong, certainly when decentralized organs don't understand the main goal and don't see the big problems that some minor issues can cause.
Agenda Setting plays also a role here. It was essential that NS, who lacked the financial means to buy a good high-speed train, ordered some trains quickly so the high-speed rail line could function when the construction was finished. They have thus had to make a quick decision, about a huge longterm project. In such a case, prioritizing external stimuli in a good way is very difficult.
Again, the organizational codes of a company  -that was the state-monopolist for a very long time- might have had some adaption problems. A market full of competitors combined with an expensive prestige project, was apparently not a good combination for NS.


Blog based on NRC-article:
http://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2013/06/03/teruglezen-nrc-reconstructie-van-het-debacle-rond-de-fyra/

No comments:

Post a Comment